I usually don't pay attention to the site medals, but I do log in every day to my dashboard (to check on a few things) and the site is always showing me the "Enthusiast" one.
Today I just noticed that the site is showing me the "Enthusiast II" medal. At least I can confirm that mine was A LOT higher than that one.
There is another thread that you can find here that is discussing the same issue. This would be something Eric would have to look into when he has time.